Glasgow Celtic and Glasgow Rangers should not join the
English Leagues.
The main reasons are
1)
People would think Scotland was part of England,
if our biggest sides played in the English leagues.
2)
Celtic and Rangers might go decades without wining
domestic trophies like other big sides like Leeds United, Everton, Spurs, West
Ham United, Coventry City and Newcastle United.
3)
All the Scottish trophies would be relegated to
the status of non-league trophies. So all those trophies Celtic, Rangers,
Aberdeen, Hearts and Hibs have won in over 100 years of history would be
relegated to the status of non-league trophies.
So people would think Celtic and Rangers have won no trophies. Which
would be a humiliating.
4)
Celtic and Rangers might have to start at the
bottom of the English system. So it could take decades to reach the English
Premier League. What is the point in giving up European football to play in the
non-league system?
5)
They might get rid of the Scottish national side
if the Old Firm joined the English leagues.
6)
We could lose a vital part of our identity.
7)
Attendances, TV rights and sponsorship would
collapse in the Scottish league.
8)
Scottish clubs might never reach the Champions
League group stages again.
9)
Scottish clubs would only rarely reach the
Europa League group stages.
10)
The Scottish league would no longer decide who
the best team in Scotland are. It would be for the teams who aren’t good enough
play in the English leagues.
The Chaos Logic.
I have heard people say well Scottish football is so
uncompetitive, or so rubbish, or so boring, that we have nothing to lose in
getting rid of Celtic and Rangers from the Scottish Leagues.
But that is nonsense. At present we have the 8th
strongest league in UEFA. We had Rangers reaching the Europa League final. And Celtic
getting to the Europa conference league knockout stages.
We are not a bad league. And if we gave up Celtic and Rangers
from the league our league would collapse. We would be like the Welsh and
Northern Irish league. Our league champions would be beaten by teams from San
Marino, Andorra and the Faroe Islands,
One of our top teams losing 7-1 to Liverpool the Champions
League runners-up, is bad. But compare that to the Scottish Champions losing
7-1 to a team from the Irish league or Denmark. Which is what would happen.
We do not need to destroy Scottish football just because the
Old Firm lost heavily to one of the best teams in the World.
Man Utd lost 6-3 to Man City recentely. Does that mean Man
Utd should join the English bottom tier and spend 20 years working their way up
again?
The well you never know attitude-
Some idiots claim that attitude of well; you never know what
could happen?
But that is a apocalyptic logic.
They think that if the Old Firm joined the English leagues
then the likes of Ross County, Dunfermline, or St Johnstone would start getting
20,000 fans at matches and would beat Juventus in the Champions League Final.
And that Celtic and Rangers would win the EPL each year.
Well I can tell you that is fantasy land. What would really
happen is.
The Scottish league would be like the Irish and Welsh league.
Our teams would struggle to get over 4000 fans at matches at best. Our teams
would not get further than the Europa League Group stages in Europe. Football
would collapse as a national sport because our fans would all turn to English football
like Ireland and Wales.
Instead of Scottish people supporting Celtic and Rangers
they would support English clubs instead.
We would go from having the 8th strongest league
in Europe to one of the worst 5 or 6 leagues in Europe. And I mean a league on a par with San Marino
and Andorra.
The Better Option
What I cannot understand is why we do not simply go for the
best of both worlds. Where we keep our own Scottish, Welsh and English and big
clubs, but have cross border cups on top of domestic and European football.
Like the best of both worlds so Glasgow Celtic, Glasgow Rangers,
Aberdeen, Motherwell, Hearts, Hibs and Dundee United can still qualify for
Europe, but also play extra Pan-Great Britain Cups on top of that.
Have a system where Motherwell, Aberdeen, Hearts can make
lots of money from Pan-Great Britain Cups, so THEN have the finances to
challenge the Old Firm for the Scottish League. So we actually have non-Old
Firm teams wining the Scottish League with the Old Firm still in the league.
The Scottish have been allowed Northern Irish and Welsh
sides in the Scottish Challenge Cup.
My ideas include;
1.
Bring back the Anglo Scottish Cup.
2.
Merge the Scottish League Cup, Welsh League Cup
and English League Cup as the Great Britain Cup. A group stage trophy.
3.
Invite Celtic and Rangers as guests in the
English FA Cup.
4.
Invite all Scottish Premiership sides not in
Europe, and selected Welsh Cymru Premier sides into the English Football League
Trophy.
5.
Invite all Scottish Premiership and Scottish
Championship sides not in Europe and all Welsh Cymru Premier sides into the
non-league FA Trophy.
6.
Invite Celtic, Rangers, two other Scottish
sides, and two best Welsh league sides to play in a cross border Great Britain
Premier Cup for all EPL sides that have not qualified for Europe.
7.
Have a Celtic Club Cup with all Scottish Premier
sides, and selected sides from Ireland, Wales, Brittany, The Isle of Man and
Cornwall.
I am not ant-English. I think we can have 3 strong national
leagues in Great Britain, not just one. The English league is one of the
strongest in the World. The Scottish
league is one of the strongest in Europe. But the Scottish and Welsh leagues could
grow with extra Pan Great Britain Cups on top of European and domestic football.